La Carlucci denigra Maiani - Glashow risponde
-
- Capitano
- Messaggi: 5404
- Iscritto il: 14 ott 2002, 14:17
- Località: Bologna
- Contatta:
La Carlucci denigra Maiani - Glashow risponde
Lettera della Carlucci, che chiede che a Luciano Maiani venga impedita la presidenza del CNR.
http://www.puglialive.net/home/news_det.php?nid=10245
Il premio Nobel Glashow, che ha collaborato con Maiani (chi e' del settore mi ha spiegato che Maiani è corresponsabile della teoria
GIM (Glashow-Iliopoulos-Maiani) che propone un'estensione del classico modello a quark per correggere certe anomalie incontrate nella teoria elettrodebole -praticamente introduce il quark C, Charm poi osservato sperimentalmente), tirato in ballo, si in_ca_zza e replica a dovere:
February 14, 2008
>
>
> Sr. Romano Prodi
> Prime Minister
>
> Dear Sir:
> I have been shown the contents of a slanderous letter written to you
> by S.ra Gabriella Carlucci, MP and dated February 7, 2008.
>
> This letter was published in Puglia-Live and has been widely
> disseminated.
>
> It falsely claims that I have questioned the scientific competence of
> Prof. Luciano Maiani, the recently elected President of the CNR, and
> had opposed his appointment at CERN.
>
> These utterly invidious and untrue allegations were part of a more
> general attempt to belittle the scientific standing of Prof. Maiani.
> The letter denigrates his scientific accomplishments over the years
> and those of his colleagues, Profs. Cabibbo, Parisi and Petronzio,
> whose work was claimed to have caused serious damage to the image of
> Italian physics worldwide. Not so!
>
> The remarks that S.ra. Carlucci attributes to me are wholly untrue and
> malicious.
> Prof. Maiani played a key role in our collaboration decades ago, for
> which he was duly recognized internationally by the awards of the
> highly regarded Dirac Medal and Sakurai Prize. Maiani's many research
> publications have been cited well over 8000 times (not including the
> 3600 citations to our joint work).
>
> I have never written, suggested or thought anything remotely
> disparaging about the skill and accomplishments of this stellar
> Italian scientist.
> The more general arguments in S.ra. Carlucci's letter are equally
> false, slanderous and malicious.
> I, and my colleagues worldwide, have the highest regard for the many
> outstanding contributions of Italian theorists to particle physics,
> among whom Profs. Cabibbo, Petronzio and Parisi (as well as Maiani)
> are leading luminaries and indeed may be regarded as' 'heirs to
Fermi.'
>
> No event associated with their distinguished scientific careers has
> ever caused the slightest damage to the image of Italian physics.
> In the eyes of a foreign scholar, if there is anything that can damage
> the image of your country's scientific institutions, it is the
> vulgarity and deception of this slanderous attempt at denigration of
> some of your nation's most distinguished scientists.
>
> Sincerely,
> Sheldon L. Glashow
> Nobel Laureate
> Foreign Member, Accademia dei Lincei
>
Michele Amadesi, illustrazioni e disegni
e-mail: info@sektoralpha.it
Portfolio on line e sito web personale --> Sektor Alpha
http://www.puglialive.net/home/news_det.php?nid=10245
Il premio Nobel Glashow, che ha collaborato con Maiani (chi e' del settore mi ha spiegato che Maiani è corresponsabile della teoria
GIM (Glashow-Iliopoulos-Maiani) che propone un'estensione del classico modello a quark per correggere certe anomalie incontrate nella teoria elettrodebole -praticamente introduce il quark C, Charm poi osservato sperimentalmente), tirato in ballo, si in_ca_zza e replica a dovere:
February 14, 2008
>
>
> Sr. Romano Prodi
> Prime Minister
>
> Dear Sir:
> I have been shown the contents of a slanderous letter written to you
> by S.ra Gabriella Carlucci, MP and dated February 7, 2008.
>
> This letter was published in Puglia-Live and has been widely
> disseminated.
>
> It falsely claims that I have questioned the scientific competence of
> Prof. Luciano Maiani, the recently elected President of the CNR, and
> had opposed his appointment at CERN.
>
> These utterly invidious and untrue allegations were part of a more
> general attempt to belittle the scientific standing of Prof. Maiani.
> The letter denigrates his scientific accomplishments over the years
> and those of his colleagues, Profs. Cabibbo, Parisi and Petronzio,
> whose work was claimed to have caused serious damage to the image of
> Italian physics worldwide. Not so!
>
> The remarks that S.ra. Carlucci attributes to me are wholly untrue and
> malicious.
> Prof. Maiani played a key role in our collaboration decades ago, for
> which he was duly recognized internationally by the awards of the
> highly regarded Dirac Medal and Sakurai Prize. Maiani's many research
> publications have been cited well over 8000 times (not including the
> 3600 citations to our joint work).
>
> I have never written, suggested or thought anything remotely
> disparaging about the skill and accomplishments of this stellar
> Italian scientist.
> The more general arguments in S.ra. Carlucci's letter are equally
> false, slanderous and malicious.
> I, and my colleagues worldwide, have the highest regard for the many
> outstanding contributions of Italian theorists to particle physics,
> among whom Profs. Cabibbo, Petronzio and Parisi (as well as Maiani)
> are leading luminaries and indeed may be regarded as' 'heirs to
Fermi.'
>
> No event associated with their distinguished scientific careers has
> ever caused the slightest damage to the image of Italian physics.
> In the eyes of a foreign scholar, if there is anything that can damage
> the image of your country's scientific institutions, it is the
> vulgarity and deception of this slanderous attempt at denigration of
> some of your nation's most distinguished scientists.
>
> Sincerely,
> Sheldon L. Glashow
> Nobel Laureate
> Foreign Member, Accademia dei Lincei
>
Michele Amadesi, illustrazioni e disegni
e-mail: info@sektoralpha.it
Portfolio on line e sito web personale --> Sektor Alpha
- TheGib
- Ammiraglio di Flotta
- Messaggi: 7931
- Iscritto il: 16 gen 2005, 10:21
- Località: Livorno - Italy
Bene, vedo che qualcuno se n'è accorto.
Ne parlavamo qui:
http://www.startrekitalia.com/public/to ... hichpage=3
Ne parlavamo qui:
http://www.startrekitalia.com/public/to ... hichpage=3
La nostra vera nazionalità è l'umanità. H.G.Wells
...siamo tutti un po' Garak
...siamo tutti un po' Garak
- spones
- Ammiraglio di Flotta
- Messaggi: 27635
- Iscritto il: 7 ott 2002, 7:55
- Località: Catania
- VulcanSmile
- Tenente Comandante
- Messaggi: 1917
- Iscritto il: 27 ago 2007, 13:16
- Località:
- Contatta:
-
- Capitano
- Messaggi: 5404
- Iscritto il: 14 ott 2002, 14:17
- Località: Bologna
- Contatta:
La Carlucci ha risposto a Glashow:
Michele Amadesi, illustrazioni e disegni
e-mail: info@sektoralpha.it
Portfolio on line e sito web personale --> Sektor Alpha
Caro Prof. Glashow, Lei ha scritto al Presidente Prodi insultandomi brutalmente senza però andare alla sostanza delle cose. La informo che i contenuti della lettera che ha suscitato la Sua ira vengono da notizie pubblicate su quotidiani italiani, su Nature e su “Lettere al Nuovo Cimento”. Notizie mai smentite.
Le scrivo solo ora per porLe una semplice domanda: se Maiani e i suoi amici sono, come Lei dice, luminari stellari stimatissimi in tutto il mondo, perché non hanno mai vinto il premio Nobel?
Eppure la Fisica della Particella italiana (e, in particolare, quella romana) è in percentuale e in valore assoluto fra le meglio finanziate al mondo. Sperò mi risponderà senza insultarmi. E non dica bugie: potrei sorprenderLa.
Cordiali saluti. Gabriella Carlucci
Michele Amadesi, illustrazioni e disegni
e-mail: info@sektoralpha.it
Portfolio on line e sito web personale --> Sektor Alpha
- spones
- Ammiraglio di Flotta
- Messaggi: 27635
- Iscritto il: 7 ott 2002, 7:55
- Località: Catania
[:ride] [:ride] [:ride] [:ride] [:ride] Non ci posso credereeeeeeeeee!!! [:ride] [:ride] [:ride] [:ride] [:ride]se Maiani e i suoi amici sono, come Lei dice, luminari stellari stimatissimi in tutto il mondo, perché non hanno mai vinto il premio Nobel?
Sono sicuro che adesso Mr.Glashow si sta ca..ndo addosso...potrei sorprenderLa.
"Those people who think they know everything are a great annoyance to those of us who do."
Isaac Asimov
Isaac Asimov
------------------------------
Denny Crane
- VulcanSmile
- Tenente Comandante
- Messaggi: 1917
- Iscritto il: 27 ago 2007, 13:16
- Località:
- Contatta:
Ormazad in effetti dovrei fare un passo indietro.
Lo pseudosillogismo corretto sarebbe: la carlucci è in politica, la nomina è politica, la carlucci c'entra.
D'accordo.
Il mio passo indietro è: la carlucci è in politica? QUESTO è dadaismo.
Ne consegue che anche "la carlucci c'entra", discendendo dalla premessa, è dadaismo.
"I have a dream; a dream that all people... Humans, Jem'Hadar, Ferengi, Cardassians... will someday stand together in peace... around my Dabo tables." (Quark)
Lo pseudosillogismo corretto sarebbe: la carlucci è in politica, la nomina è politica, la carlucci c'entra.
D'accordo.
Il mio passo indietro è: la carlucci è in politica? QUESTO è dadaismo.
Ne consegue che anche "la carlucci c'entra", discendendo dalla premessa, è dadaismo.
"I have a dream; a dream that all people... Humans, Jem'Hadar, Ferengi, Cardassians... will someday stand together in peace... around my Dabo tables." (Quark)
- TheGib
- Ammiraglio di Flotta
- Messaggi: 7931
- Iscritto il: 16 gen 2005, 10:21
- Località: Livorno - Italy
- VulcanSmile
- Tenente Comandante
- Messaggi: 1917
- Iscritto il: 27 ago 2007, 13:16
- Località:
- Contatta:
-
- Tenente Comandante
- Messaggi: 1880
- Iscritto il: 15 giu 2004, 22:51
- Località: Torino
- Contatta:
-
- Capitano
- Messaggi: 5404
- Iscritto il: 14 ott 2002, 14:17
- Località: Bologna
- Contatta:
Glashow controbatte:
http://www.puglialive.net/home/news_det.php?nid=10554
Dear Sra Carlucci,
Despite your earlier comments and whatever your sources may be, the fact is that I have never questioned Prof. Maiani’s stature as a superb and accomplished researcher. I am outraged that you have tarnished my own reputation by such a false and invidious allegation. It is true that several Italian theorists (including Maiani) are deserving of Nobel Prizes, but there are far more such candidates than Prizes. Recall that world-renowned physics luminaries such as Edward Witten, Stephen Hawking, Yoichiro Nambu, among many others, are not Nobel Laurestes.
Whether (or not) Italian physicists have won Nobel Prizes, and whether (or not) they are well funded, they have made exceptional contributions to physics, at least as many as any other European nation.
Italy should be very proud of its many scientific heroes, and not malign them.
Sincerely
Sheldon Lee Glashow
Michele Amadesi, illustrazioni e disegni
e-mail: info@sektoralpha.it
Portfolio on line e sito web personale --> Sektor Alpha
http://www.puglialive.net/home/news_det.php?nid=10554
Dear Sra Carlucci,
Despite your earlier comments and whatever your sources may be, the fact is that I have never questioned Prof. Maiani’s stature as a superb and accomplished researcher. I am outraged that you have tarnished my own reputation by such a false and invidious allegation. It is true that several Italian theorists (including Maiani) are deserving of Nobel Prizes, but there are far more such candidates than Prizes. Recall that world-renowned physics luminaries such as Edward Witten, Stephen Hawking, Yoichiro Nambu, among many others, are not Nobel Laurestes.
Whether (or not) Italian physicists have won Nobel Prizes, and whether (or not) they are well funded, they have made exceptional contributions to physics, at least as many as any other European nation.
Italy should be very proud of its many scientific heroes, and not malign them.
Sincerely
Sheldon Lee Glashow
Michele Amadesi, illustrazioni e disegni
e-mail: info@sektoralpha.it
Portfolio on line e sito web personale --> Sektor Alpha
-
- Tenente Comandante
- Messaggi: 1880
- Iscritto il: 15 giu 2004, 22:51
- Località: Torino
- Contatta:
- VulcanSmile
- Tenente Comandante
- Messaggi: 1917
- Iscritto il: 27 ago 2007, 13:16
- Località:
- Contatta:
Chi c’è in linea
Visitano il forum: Nessuno e 16 ospiti